Might intrinsic radioresistance of human tumour cells be induced by radiation?

Abstract

Survival measurements were made on six human tumour cell lines in vitro after irradiation with single doses of X rays. Doses up to 5 Gy were used giving surviving fractions down to 20%, but the majority of the measurements were made at doses < 1 Gy. These six cell lines have very different intrinsic radiosensitivities: HT29, Be11, and RT112 are radioresistant with surviving fractions at 2 Gy (SF2) between 60 and 74%, while MeWo, SW48, and HX142 are radiosensitive (SF2 = 3-29%). For all the cell lines, response over the dose range 2-5 Gy showed a good fit to a Linear-Quadratic (LQ) model. However, HT29, Be11, and RT112 cells showed a significant increase in X-ray radiosensitivity at doses below < 1 Gy compared with the prediction extrapolated from a LQ model fitted to the data at higher doses. The LQ model also slightly underpredicted the effect of low-dose X rays in MeWo cells, but the response of SW48 and HX142 cells was well described by the LQ model at all doses, with no evidence of increased low-dose effectiveness. The most plausible explanation for this phenomenon is that it reflects an induced radioresistance so that low doses of X-rays in vitro are more effective per Gy than higher doses, because only at higher doses is there sufficient damage to trigger repair systems or other radioprotective mechanisms. It follows that variation in the amount of inducible radioresistance might explain, in part, differences in intrinsic radiosensitivity above > 1 Gy between cell lines: cells would be intrinsically radiosensitive because they have a diminished inducible response.