Midwifery students' expectations of and experiences with ethics education: A qualitative study

Abstract

BackgroundInstruction in ethics is an essential component of midwifery education. However, the evidence for how midwifery students experience ethics instruction in the classroom and via clinical experience is limited. ObjectiveThis study explores midwifery students' perceptions of ethics education and their opinions about essential components of ethics education. DesignThis was a qualitative descriptive thematic study, exploring student midwives' experiences of ethics education in their midwifery programs. We conducted focus group interviews with students from three midwifery programs in the United States (U.S.). SettingGraduate midwifery educational programs in the United States. ParticipantsThirty-nine students from three graduate midwifery programs participated in four focus group discussions. ResultsThematic analysis identified three primary themes and associated subthemes: 1) current experience and identified needs, 2) the preceptor dilemma, with subthemes the critical role of modeling ethics and powerlessness within interprofessional conflicts, and 3) complicated relationships: advocacy, autonomy and choice. Students relied primarily upon clinical preceptors rather than classroom discussion as a significant source of learning ethics content and ethical behavior. Students called for explicit identification of ethics learning when it occurs, particularly midwifery-specific content, as well as increased opportunities for reflection and integration of their experiences. ConclusionThis study shows the need for intentional inclusion of midwifery-specific ethics content into the overall midwifery education program content, in both classroom and clinical experiences. Midwifery programs should integrate ethics content in their curricula in a way that complements other midwifery content. This study also demonstrates the key role of clinical preceptors in student ethics learning.