Mid-oceanic carbonate platforms as oceanic dipsticks: examples from the Pacific

Abstract

Framebuilders of Cenozoic coral reefs are limited by their photic requirements to the contemporaneous sea-level, and therefore shallow water reef facies are reliable paleo sea-level indicators. Sea-level lowstands leave no record on coral reefs in areas subject to tectonic uplift, such as the Huon Peninsula, New Guinea, but are recorded by coral reefs in areas subject to tectonic subsidence. A eustatic sea-level fall which exceeds the rate of subsidence subaeriallyexposes the upper section of the reef complex, creating a meteoric ground water system whose diagenetic imprint on the reef carbonates offers a good indicator of a sea-level stillstand. Cenozoic reef platforms thus may contain records of sea-level fluctuations, whether eustatic and global, or tectonic and local. Those reef platforms which developed on seamounts formed in mid-oceanic plate settings are particularly useful for the study of eustatic sea-level changes because their subsidence history is relatively simple, and the tectonic factor can be accounted for when estimating the eustatic sea-level component. Conventional petrographic and biostratigraphic methods used to delineate erosional unconformities in Cenozoic carbonate sections are often deficient. We demonstrate here that stable oxygen and carbon isotopes of the carbonates can reveal the location of both the exposure surface and the paleo water table with greater confidence on account of the specific imprint of meteoric diagenesis. In addition, the87Sr/86Sr isotope technique offers a promising dating tool of disconformities linked to sea-level lowstands with a resolution superior to the conventional biostratigraphic techniques. Although oxygen, carbon, and strontium isotopes monitor different aspects of global sea-level changes, when used in conjunction they provide deeper insights into the past than either one could achieve alone. Examples from previous and ongoing studies of Pacific mid-oceanic carbonate platforms illustrate the potential of the isotope techniques to unravel sea-level changes. At Midway Atoll, stable carbon and oxygen isotopes along with lithologic and biostratigraphic data suggest a sharp eustatic sealevel fall during the Early Miocene and a series of rapid, brief eustatic fluctuations during the Pliocene-Quaternary. The frequency and timing of the latter is supported by sea-level data from Enewetak Atoll obtained on the basis of detailed strontium isotopes and lithology. The Enewetak data also indicate a series of rapid, brief eustatic fluctuations around the Early-Middle Miocene boundary. At Niue, a carbonate platform about 500 km south of Samoa, oxygen, carbon, and strontium isotope records cover the critical interval of the Miocene-Pliocene boundary and show two distinct disconformities. The mid-oceanic carbonate platforms offer a testing ground of “Vail-Haq type” eustatic sea-level curves derived primarily from sections along passive continental margins and continental interiors. We show that Neogene sea-level data obtained from Midway, Enewetak, and Niue differ from Vail and Hardenbol's contemporaneous sea-level curve and support Haq et al.'s version.