Microsatellite instability but not thymidylate synthase is a prognostic variable in primary colon cancers from patients treated in 5-FU-based adjuvant studies

Abstract

10019 Background: Colon cancers with microsatellite instability (MSI) display resistance to 5-fluorouracil (5-FU), and in vitro resistance can be reversed by restoring DNA mismatch repair proficiency. 5-FU inhibits the thymidylate synthase (TS) enzyme and TS may predict clinical outcome after 5-FU-based chemotherapy. To define molecular predictors of prognosis, we analyzed TS, p53, chromosome 17p allelic imbalance (AI), and patient survival stratified by MSI status. Methods: Primary colon carcinomas from patients enrolled in five 5-FU-based adjuvant therapy trials were analyzed for MSI and 17p AI using 11 microsatellite markers (MSI-H: ≥ 30% of the loci demonstrating instability). For 17p AI, markers included D17S261 and TP53 at or near the p53 locus. Expression of DNA mismatch repair (hMLH1, PharMingen; hMSH2; Oncogene), TS (TS106, Zymed), and p53 (D07, Novacastra) proteins were analyzed by immunohistochemistry. Correlations between markers and associations with overall survival (OS) were determined. Patients were censored at 5 years for DFS and at 8 years post study randomization for overall survival (OS) data. Results: Of 320 Dukes’ stage B2 and C cancers studied, 60 of 320 (19%) were MSI-H. TS expression variables (intensity, extent, weighted score) were similar in MSI-H and MSI stable/low frequency (MSS/MSI-L) cancers; similar results were found using DNA mismatch repair (dMMR) proteins. MSI-H tumors had lower stage (p= 0.0007), fewer metastatic lymph nodes (p= 0.004), and improved OS (vs. MSS/MSI-L tumors; p= 0.01). Loss of dMMR proteins was also associated with better OS (p= 0.006). None of the TS variables were prognostic for OS. Histologic grade (p= 0.0008) and nodal status (p= 0.0002) were associated with OS in contrast to 17p LOH or p53. Only MSI status or dMMR, histologic grade, and tumor stage were independent markers for OS. Conclusions: MSI-H tumors show earlier stage at presentation and better stage-adjusted survival rates. MSI status and TS expression were unrelated and TS was not prognostic, suggesting that TS levels cannot explain therapeutic resistance to 5-FU reported in MSI-H colon cancers. [Table: see text]