Micronutrient Fortified Drink Over 18 Months Had No Impact on Stunting: A RCT in Rural Guatemala

Abstract

Abstract Objectives To determine the long-term impact of a micronutrient fortified supplement on stunting rates and micronutrient status in young children living in rural Guatemala, which has the highest stunting prevalence in Latin America. Methods A parallel, open label randomised control trial in rural children aged 6–72 months (Registration NCT01643187). After growth screening, all children < 1SD for either weight for height (WHZ), height for age (HAZ), or weight for age (WAZ) were randomly allocated using 7:3 ratio, stratified by locality and age to receive either the test drink, Chispuditos®, a corn/soy beverage fortified with 21 vitamins or de-lactosed milk (control). Both drinks were isoproteic (4g/drink) and had similar energy content (test drink 147 kcal, milk 117 kcal) but the tst drink had higher micronutrient content (e.g., 9 mg zinc, 12.5 mg iron vs 1.5 mg zinc, 1.9 mg iron in control). They were supplied for 18 months and monthly visits were conducted to test for adherence. Results A total of 1238 children were screened, 971 met the criteria and 681 were allocated to test drink and 290 to control. At baseline, malnutrition prevalence of stunting (HAZ < -2SD), for test vs control was 48.4% vs 47.9%, 5.5% vs 6.7% for wasting (WHZ < -2SD) and 19.9% vs 18.7% for underweight (WAZ < -2SD). 73% of children reported to consume at least half of allocated drinks/day. After 18 months of intervention, the prevalence and relative risks [RR (95% CI)] for stunting in the test: control were 40.6:40.7% [RR 0.99 (0.84, 1.19)]; similarly, no differences were seen in WAZ, WHZ nor micronutrient status. Conclusions In this trial in rural Guatemalan children, long term supplementation with a micronutrient enriched drink had no impact on either stunting or micronutrient status. These results differ form long-term studies in urban Guatemalan nurseries. The present study suggest that fortified foods alone are not enough to reduce stunting rates in this setting when fed during an 18 month period. Funding Sources The Mathile Institute for the Advancement of Human Nutrition funded this study.