Microbially mediated carbon cycling as a control on the δ13C of sedimentary carbon in eutrophic Lake Mendota (USA): new models for interpreting isotopic excursions in the sedimentary record

Abstract

An isotopic study of various carbon phases in eutrophic Lake Mendota (Wisconsin, USA) indicates that the δ13C composition of sedimentary organic and inorganic carbon has become more negative in response to increasing microbially mediated carbon cycling and processes associated with the intensification of seasonal and long-term eutrophication. Progressive increases in the contributions of isotopically depleted chemoautotrophic and methanotrophic biomass (reflected in the −40 to −90‰ values of hopanols and FAMES), attributed to seasonal and long-term increases in production and expansion of the anaerobic water mass, accounts for carbon isotopic trends towards depleted δ13C values observed in both seasonal varves and over the past 100 years. Changes in the intensities of certain microbial processes are also evident in the sedimentary geochemical record. During the period of most intense cultural eutrophication, when the oxic-anoxic interface was located close to the surface, methanogenesis/methanotrophy and the oxidation of biogenic methane increased to the extent that significant quantities of 13C-depleted CO2 were added into the epilimnion. This depleted CO2 was subsequently utilized by phytoplankton and incorporated into CaCO3 during biogenically induced calcite precipitation. A comparative study between eutrophic Lakes Mendota and Greifen, further indicate that the extent of nutrient loading in the epilimnion determines whether the δ13C record of sedimentary organic carbon reflects intensification of microbial processes in the hypolimnion and sediments, or changes in the primary productivity in the photic zone. From this comparison, a series of eutrophication models are developed to describe progressive transitions through thresholds of microbial and eukaryotic productivity and their influence on the δ13C record of sedimentary carbon. With increasing eutrophication, the models initially predict a negative and then a subsequent positive carbon isotopic excursion reflecting the changing influence of 13C-deleted microbial biomass relative to 13C-enriched photoautrophic biomass. These eutrophication models provide a framework to evaluate carbon cycling processes in modern environments and have significant implications for interpreting carbon isotopic excursions in the sedimentary record.