Methane foam performance in oil-wet unconsolidated porous media: A systematic experimental investigation at reservoir conditions

Abstract

Methane foam performance was systematically evaluated using high-pressure and high-temperature experiments performed on oil-wet proppant packs. The sensitivities of foam performance to various key factors, including surfactant concentration, foam quality, total injection rate, salinity, operating pressure, and initial oil saturation were examined. The results showed that even though the foamability and foam strength in oil-wet proppant packs were adversely affected by wettability and presence of oil, the steady-state pressure drops across the proppant packs were insensitive to the quantity of oil initially present. The presence of oil above the critical oil saturation impeded the onset of foam generation. This suggested that the foamability of surfactants depends on the synergetic effects of surfactant’s ionic nature and foam parameters, such as foam quality and total injection rate, on their ability to reduce the oil saturation to a threshold value below which favorable bubble generation sites could be created. It was observed that, for low injection rate, anionic surfactant was ineffective at low salinity conditions, while amphoteric agent performed well at all salinities. Additionally, an increase in salinity resulted in enhanced pressure drop across the proppant packs for both anionic and amphoteric surfactants. The results also established that too high operating pressures are somewhat detrimental to the foam strength and stability, irrespective of the ionic nature of foaming agents and the wettability of the porous medium. For the anionic surfactant, the increase in the total flow rate was found to mitigate the adverse effects of low salt concentration and operating pressure. Results from quality-sensitivity foam tests identified two regions for the foam behavior, named low-quality and high-quality regimes, separated by the transition foam quality. Finally, we discuss the implications of the results for the design and effective implementation of enhanced oil recovery (EOR) schemes that deploy hydrocarbon-based foams.