Metastasectomy for melanoma in the VATS era

Abstract

e20001 Background: The role for metastasectomy in the setting of metastatic melanoma remains ill-defined. The aim of this study is to evaluate resection of limited metastases in the setting of melanoma comparing VATS and open approaches, specifically looking at perioperative morbidity and survival. Methods: All patients undergoing metastasectomy for melanoma with curative intent between January 1, 2001 and September 30, 2007 were included. Data was collected retrospectively from the UPMC tumor registry and chart review. Differences between groups were compared with the student's t-test. Results: Of 43 patients undergoing metastasectomy for melanoma, 31 patients were resected with intent to cure (16 VATS, 15 open). Complications were similar between the VATS (12%) and open (13%) groups. There were no perioperative deaths in either group. The median survival in the VATS group was 20.7 months, compared to 26.5 months in the open group (p = 0.17). Importantly, the VATS patients more frequently underwent resection of smaller, peripheral lesions via wedge resection (81%) and only 2 patients (13%) underwent lobectomy. Conversely, patients undergoing open procedures were more likely to have larger, more central lesions and undergo anatomic resections. There were 9 (60%) lobectomies, 3 (20%) segmentectomies 1 (7%) en bloc resection and only 2 (13%) wedge resections in the open group. Conclusions: Metastasectomy for metastatic melanoma in the thoracic cavity can be performed safely by a VATS or open approach. The two approaches have comparable morbidity, mortality and survival outcomes. Careful patient resection remains the hallmark of care in identifying appropriate candidates for metastasectomy. In the setting of patients with short life-expectancy, it may be advantageous to employ a VATS approach when possible to preserve quality of life while achieving similar oncologic outcomes to open procedures. Individuals with a radiographic indication of limited peripheral disease should be considered for a VATS approach to resection of melanoma metastases. No significant financial relationships to disclose.