Metabolic regimes of three mid-order streams in southern Ontario, Canada exposed to contrasting sources of nutrients

Abstract

Light, temperature, and discharge control stream metabolism, but the response of gross primary production (GPP) and ecosystem respiration (ER) to seasonal variation in these physical drivers may differ in accordance with the types of human activities present in the catchment. Our study examined three mid-order streams in southern Ontario, Canada that differed in anthropogenic nutrient sources (i.e., sewage treatment plant effluent, sewage lagoon effluent, and agriculture), but had comparable light, temperature, and discharge regimes. For each stream, GPP and ER were estimated daily from June through November. Comparisons of paired daily metabolic rates revealed pairwise differences among all streams, with streams receiving sewage effluent having greater rates and variability of GPP and ER than the stream draining agricultural land. The two sewage influenced streams differed only in ER. Temporal patterns of GPP and ER were correlated for all streams throughout the study period and were most affected by seasonal variation in temperature, whereby effluent receiving streams responded more rapidly to increases in temperature. Our findings suggest that managers may need to balance effects of human activities with regional environmental constraints on stream metabolism to maintain and enhance the ecological condition and services of stream ecosystems.