Menopausal hormone therapy and sleep-disordered breathing: evidence for a healthy user bias

Abstract

PurposeObservational studies suggest that menopausal hormone therapy protects against sleep-disordered breathing, but such findings may be biased by a “healthy user effect.” When the Women's Health Initiative Study reported in 2002 that estrogen-progestin therapy increases heart disease risk, many women discontinued hormone therapy. We investigate healthy user bias in the association of hormone therapy with sleep-disordered breathing in the Sleep in Midlife Women Study. MethodsA total of 228 women aged 38 to 62 years were recruited from the Wisconsin Sleep Cohort Study. They underwent polysomnography to measure apnea-hypopnea index, at home semiannually from 1997 to 2006, and in the sleep laboratory every four years (n = 1828 studies). Hormone therapy was recorded monthly. Linear models with empirical standard errors regressed logarithm of apnea-hypopnea index on hormone use with a pre- or post-July 2002 interaction, adjusting for menopause and age. ResultsThe association of hormone therapy and sleep-disordered breathing was heterogeneous (P < .01); apnea-hypopnea index among users was 15% lower in the early period (95% confidence interval, −27% to −1%), but similar to nonusers in the late. ConclusionsHormone therapy was negatively associated with sleep-disordered breathing only until the Women's Health Initiative results were publicized. Hormone therapy may have been a marker for healthfulness in the early period, creating a spurious association with sleep-disordered breathing.