Medical Error as a Challenge in Iran’s Health System

Abstract

1. Definition of Medical Error Medical error (ME) is defined as any error in carrying out planned action or any incorrect action for achieving a purpose in the health care system. These errors may arise in process, performance, product or system (1). Medical errors (MEs) in delivery of healthcare are a major threat to patients’ safety (2) and could occur in any healthcare organization e.g. hospital, health center, laboratory, clinic etc. Moreover, preventable MEs are a leading cause of medical injuries worldwide (1). Medical error is a challenge in every country (e.g. about 225000 patients die annually in the United State as a result of ME), and health systems suffer from human and economic expenditures (costs imposed on both health systems and patients due to these errors) (2). In addition, it is one of the main causes of increasing complaints in hospitals and prolongs the hospital stay and in some cases results in death (2, 3). Although there are various categorizations of MEs, classification to human errors (such as medication, diagnosis, prescription, documentation, treatment and coordination), systemic errors (administrational or organizational and process) and technical errors is the most common MEs categorization (4). 2. Reasons of Medical Error The causes of ME vary such as misidentification (5), stress, crowding in wards, heavy workload, burnout, lack of communication among healthcare professionals, medical knowledge deficiency and not writing the drug form and drug dose by physicians, which could be potentially harmful to patients (6-8). The lack of reporting MEs through medical staff is another cause of increasing ME in hospitals (4). 3. Medical Error; a Challenge in Iran As mentioned above, ME is a challenge in every country especially in Eastern Mediterranean region such as Iran (about 4.4 million MEs occurred in countries in the Eastern Mediterranean region) (9). The high rate of ME in some hospitals in Iran confirms the mentioned challenge (2) and it is known as a challenge in all hospitals in Iran, especially in public hospitals (4, 6). Although there is an ME registration system in most hospitals, with both voluntary and mandatory approach, its prevalence is not clear. Nevertheless, a study indicated that the prevalence of medication errors at different stages were as follows: prescribing (47.8%), transcribing (51.8%), dispensing (33.6%) and administration (70%) (10). On the other hands, some of hospital managers declared that among 100 to 150 patients, one person dies from ME in hospitals, and the statistic of ME in 2012 was higher than that of 2011 (12%) (11). Moreover, 24% of complaints against physicians are about death related to MEs (12). In general, in Iranian hospitals the highest frequency of MEs is related to systemic, administration and drug errors (2, 13). In addition, individual factors such as miscalculations of doses and inadequate knowledge of medications were the most frequent contributing factors in MEs among nurses (14). Some studies in Iran showed that more of 50% of MEs occurred in larger hospitals (2, 15). In addition, internal wards and morning shift, and also crowded ward are other influential factors in the incidence of MEs (2). Notably, nurses and physicians commit the most of errors in hospitals in Iran, respectively (67.3% and 20.2%) (4). According to the mentioned sentences, it is needed to be more sensitive about ME in healthcare organizations and prevention strategies must be used for decrease this challenge. 4. Prevention Strategies The goal of error reduction and increased productivity and accuracy can be achieved through a system-focused approach that focuses on the process and has a systematic attitude. Top managers and staff should pay more attention to MEs reducing policies and strategies in health systems,