Medical device similarity analysis: a promising approach to medical device equivalence regulation

Abstract

ABSTRACT Background This study aims to facilitate the identification of similar devices for both, the European Medical Device Regulation (MDR) and the US 510(k) equivalence pathway by leveraging existing data. Both are related to the regulatory pathway of read across for chemicals, where toxicological data from a known substance is transferred to one under investigation, as they aim to streamline the accreditation process for new devices and chemicals. Research design and methods This study employs latent semantic analysis to generate similarity values, harnessing the US Food and Drug Administration 510k-database, utilizing their ‘Device Descriptions’ and ‘Intended Use’ statements. Results For the representative inhaler cluster, similarity values up to 0.999 were generated for devices within a 510(k)-predicate tree, whereas values up to 0.124 were gathered for devices outside this group. Conclusion Traditionally, MDR equivalence involves manual review of many devices, which is laborious. However, our results suggest that the automated calculation of similarity coefficients streamlines this process, thus reducing regulatory effort, which can be beneficial for patients needing medical devices. Although this study is focused on the European perspective, it can find application within 510(k) equivalence regulation. The conceptual approach is reminiscent of chemical fingerprint similarity analysis employed in read-across.