Mechanistic Insights for Formation of an Organometallic Co–C Bond in the Methyl Transfer Reaction Catalyzed by Methionine Synthase

Abstract

Methionine synthase (MetH) catalyzes the transfer of a methyl group from methyltetrahydrofolate (CH3-H4Folate) to the cob(I)alamin intermediate to form an organometallic Co-C bond, a reaction similar to that of CH3-H4Folate:corrinoid/iron-sulfur protein (CFeSP) methyltransferase (MeTr). How precisely it is formed remains elusive because the displacement of a methyl group from the tertiary amine is not a facile reaction. To understand the electronic structure and mechanistic details of the MetH-cob(I)alamin:CH3-H4Folate reaction complex, we applied quantum mechanics/molecular mechanics (QM/MM) computations. The hybrid QM/MM calculations reveal the traditionally assumed SN2 mechanism for formation the CH3-cob(III)alamin resting state where the activation energy barrier for the SN2 reaction was found to be ~8-9 kcal/mol, which is comparable with respect to the determined experimental rate constant. However, the possibility of an electron transfer (ET) based radical mechanism consistent with the close-lying diradical states observed from triplet and open-shell singlet states has also been suggested as an alternative, where first an electron transfer from His-on cob(I)alamin to the pterin ring of the protonated CH3-H4Folate takes place, forming the Co(II)(d(7))-pterin radical (π*)(1) diradical state, followed by a methyl radical transfer. Although the predicted energy barrier for the ET-mediated radical reaction is comparable to that of the SN2 pathway, the major advantage of ET is that a methyl radical can be transferred at a longer distance, which does not require the close proximity of two binding modules of MetH as does the SN2 type. In addition, based on the energy barrier of the transition state (TS) in both the protonated (~8-9 kcal/mol) and the unprotonated N5 (39 kcal/mol) species of the CH3-H4Folate, it can be inferred that the protonation event must takes place either prior to or during the methyl transfer reaction in a ternary complex. The results of the present study including mechanistic insights can have implications to a broad class of corrinoid-methyltransferases, which utilize a CH3-H4Folate substrate or its related analogues as methyl donor.