Mechanical evaluation of different techniques for Achilles tendon repair

Abstract

One aim of the surgical treatment of acute Achilles tendon ruptures is to obtain a maximum primary stability of the sutured tendon. Therefore, we investigated the primary stability of sutured human Achilles tendons depending on different applied techniques. The strength of 60 repaired cadaveric human Achilles tendons was tested depending on either the suture technique (Bunnell or Kessler), the suture material (PDS-thread or PDS-cord) or an additional plantaris tendon augmentation (PDS-thread with or without augmentation). Following anatomic reconstruction the repaired specimens were loaded to failure. The use of Bunnell's technique resulted in a stronger primary suture stability compared to Kessler's technique. Sutures carried out with a PDS-thread were of lower strength than those accomplished with a PDS-cord (Bunnell: thread 139 N +/- 29.8; cord 291 N +/- 55.2/Kessler: thread 137 N +/- 37.3; cord 180 N +/- 41.1). Sutures performed according to Bunnell's technique with a PDS-thread and an additional autologous plantaris tendon augmentation reached the highest primary stability (326 N +/- 124.9). The findings identify the Achilles tendon suture with a PDS-cord according to Bunnell's technique as a mechanically strong method. A plantaris tendon augmentation in addition to a PDS-thread can even add more stability to the Achilles tendon suture.