Measuring a Critical Component of Contraceptive Decision Making: The Contraceptive Concerns and Beliefs Scale

Abstract

IntroductionConcerns about safety and side effects from contraceptives are widespread and related to reluctance to use them. Measuring these concerns is an essential component of understanding contraceptive decision-making and guiding contraceptive and interpregnancy clinical care.MethodsWe used qualitative research and item response theory to develop and test a psychometric instrument to measure contraceptive concerns and beliefs. We developed 55 candidate scale items and tested them among 572 adolescents and adults across nine California healthcare facilities in 2019–2020. We derived a 6-item scale and assessed differences by age and social determinants of health with multivariable regression.ResultsIn qualitative data, participants voiced both concerns and positive beliefs about contraception. Quantitative survey respondents were aged 21 years on average, and 24% were parous. Over half (54%) worried contraception has dangerous side effects, and 39% worried it is unnatural. The mean Contraceptive Concerns score, increasing with higher concerns, was 1.85 (SD: 1.00, range 0–4, α = 0.81). Items fit a partial credit item response model and met prespecified criteria for internal structure validity. Contraceptive use declined with increasing Concerns score (adjusted prevalence ratio [aPR] = 0.81 [0.72–0.92]). Scores were elevated among Black (mean: 2.06; aβ = 0.34 [0.09, 0.59]) and Multiracial or other race (2.11; aβ = 0.34 [0.02, 0.66]) respondents vs. White (1.66), but not Latinx respondents (1.81; aβ = 0.11 [− 0.11, 0.33]). Scores were also elevated among participants with lower maternal education (high school/Associate’s 1.89 versus college 1.60; aβ = 0.28 [0.04, 0.53]).DiscussionThe psychometrically robust Concerns instrument can be used in research to measure autonomous contraceptive decision-making and to design person-centered care.