Measurement of soil CO 2 efflux using soda lime absorption: both quantitative and reliable

Abstract

Measurement of soil CO 2 efflux using a non-flow-through steady-state (NFT-SS) chamber with alkali absorption of CO 2 by soda lime was tested and compared with a flow-through non-steady-state (FT-NSS) IRGA method to assess suitability of using soda lime for field monitoring over large spatial scales and integrated over a day. Potential errors and artifacts associated with the soda lime chamber method were investigated and improvements made. The following issues relating to quantification and reliable measurement of soil CO 2 efflux were evaluated: (i) absorption capacity of the soda lime, (ii) additional and thus artifactual absorption of CO 2 by soda lime during the experimental procedure, (iii) variation in the CO 2 concentration inside the chamber headspace, and (iv) effects of chamber closure on soil CO 2 efflux. Soil CO 2 efflux, as measured using soda lime (with a range of quantities: 50, 100, and 200 g per 0.082 m 2 ground area enclosed in chamber), was compared with transient IRGA measurements as a reference method that is based on well-established physical principles, using several forms of spatial and temporal comparisons. Natural variation in efflux rates ranged from 2 to 5.5 g C m −2 day −1 between different chambers and over different days. A comparison of the IRGA-based assay with measurement based on soda lime yielded an overall correlation coefficient of 0.82. The slope of the regression line was not significantly different from the 1:1 line, and the intercept was not significantly different from the origin. This result indicated that measurement of CO 2 efflux by soda lime absorption was quantitatively similar and unbiased in relation to the reference method. The soda lime method can be a highly practical method for field measurements if implemented with due care (in terms of drying and weighing soda lime, and in minimizing leakages), and validated for specific field conditions. A detailed protocol is presented for use of the soda lime method for measurement of CO 2 efflux from field soils.