Market Fragmentation and Information Quality: The Role of TRF Trades

Abstract

We analyze and compare the information quality of order flows on the exchange and on off-exchange venues reported to Trade Reporting Facilities. Compared to exchange order flow, we find that off-exchange order flow has significantly lower information quality, including a lower information ratio and a lower price impact, and a significantly higher percentage of trades executing inside the quote. Our results are consistent with the notion that the segmentation of uninformed liquidity traders in off-exchange venues so that there is a higher proportion of informed traders on the exchanges, leads to an improvement in price discovery and information quality on the exchanges. Use of off-exchange venues is higher with increased market speed and trading intensity, but decreases with higher intraday volatility.