Managing Variable Fidelity Models in Population-based Optimization using Adaptive Model Switching

Abstract

This paper proposes a novel model management technique to be applied in populationbased heuristic optimization. This technique adaptively selects different computational models (both physics-based and statistical models) to be used during optimization, with the overall goal to end with high fidelity solutions in a reasonable time period. For example, in optimizing an aircraft wing to obtain maximum lift-to-drag ratio, one can use low-fidelity models such as given by the vortex lattice method, or a high-fidelity finite volume model (that solves the full Navier-Stokes equations), or a surrogate model that substitutes the high-fidelity model.The information from models with different levels of fidelity is integrated into the heuristic optimization process using a novel model-switching metric. In this context, models could be surrogate models, low-fidelity physics-based analytical models, and medium-to-high fidelity computational models (based on grid density). The model switching technique replaces the current model with the next higher fidelity model, when a stochastic switching criterion is met at a given iteration during the optimization process. The switching criteria is based on whether the uncertainty associated with the current model output dominates the latest improvement of the fitness function. In the case of the physics-based models, the uncertainty in their output is quantified through an inverse assessment process by comparing with high-fidelity model responses or experimental data (if available). To determine the fidelity of surrogate models, the Predictive Estimation of Model Fidelity (PEMF) method is applied. The effectiveness of the proposed method is demonstrated by applying it to airfoil optimization with the objective to maximize the lift to drag ratio of the wing under different flow regimes. It was found that the tuned low fidelity model dominates the optimization process in terms of computational time and function calls.