Managing Resident Mental Health: Prevention is Better than Cure

Abstract

There is a high prevalance of burnout and mental health illness among trainees. Through structured meetings, Program Directors (PDs) have an opportunity to screen and aid residents that may be affected by mental health concerns. However, barriers to this process exist. This study sought to evaluate the perspectives of PDs regarding mental health screening for trainees. A 13-item survey-based study. Electronic distribution of the survey was performed via three individualized requests sent via e-mail to PDs. PDs of 5 ACGME specialties, including Internal Medicine, Pediatrics, Emergency Medicine, General Surgery, and Psychiatry were invited to participate. In total, 595 PDs responded to the survey (response rate = 40.0%) In general, PDs expressed dissatisfaction with the management of burnout and mental health. Most PDs supported periodic screening of residents for burnout (87.0%) and mental health (73.9%). For a resident that could screen positive for mental illness, most PDs were concerned about the possibility of harm to a patient (70.7%) and implications for future licensing (65.7%). Only 30.2% of PDs currently use some form of standardized screening to identify residents struggling with mental health and burnout concerns. The majority of PDs across 5 ACGME specialties support the use of periodic screening of residents for burnout and mental health. However, concerns exist regarding such screening such as the implications for future licensing. Additional work needs to be done to address PD concerns and destigmatizate mental health wellbeing and care among trainees.