Managing hunted populations through sex-specific season lengths: a case of the Common Eider in the Baltic-Wadden Sea flyway population

Abstract

Management of harvested wildlife populations aims to protect species from overexploitation and ultimately extinction, by regulating exploitation towards achievable sustainable levels. However, assessments of impact and sustainability of implemented management actions on a population level are scarce. This study assesses effects of changes in hunting season length imposed on the Baltic-Wadden Sea Common Eider Somateria mollissima population, including differential restriction on hunting of the sexes. The potential impact of these changes on the population was assessed by simple demographic matrix projections. Since the early 1990s, this population has declined at ca. 6.3 % per annum, and the male/female ratio among shot birds has fallen from 3:2 to about 3:1. Concerns in Denmark regarding the conservation status and sustainability of contemporary levels of exploitation resulted in shortening the open season by 44 and 46 days for females and 13 and 15 days for males from the hunting seasons 2004/2005 and 2011/2012 onwards, respectively. These reduced the kill of adult females by 82 %, adult males by 31 %, juvenile females by 58 % and juvenile males by 55 %. The observed reduction in the kill of adult females following both changes in 2004/2005 and 2011/2012 matched the expected changes based on the seasonal distribution of sexes in the bag prior to the change. Post 2004/2005 hunters killed more adult males, but shot markedly fewer juvenile birds than expected. Demographic modelling of the female population showed that the effects of the reduced hunting would correspond to an increase in the annual population growth rate from the previous −6.3 to −3.6 % (post 2004) and −1.6 % (post 2011). The model also predicted that a full ban on hunting female eiders (adults and juveniles) would lead to a positive population growth rate of 0.7 %. Taking into account the conservative model estimates and natural variations in annual breeding success, the implemented changes in sex-specific regulation of hunting may potentially be an effective management tool to halt the decline of the Baltic-Wadden Sea eider population, potentially rendering such levels of hunting sustainable under prevailing conditions.