Management of paediatric acute appendicitis in the general hospital setting: a national survey of preferred surgical technique.

Abstract

The advent of laparoscopic surgery has facilitated the management of acute appendicitis in the adult population. In the paediatric population (<12 years), management varies according to institution and/or consultant expertise. The aim of this study was to analyse consultant preference for laparoscopic versus open appendicectomy in the management of acute appendicitis in children under 12 years presenting to general hospitals. A 15-point questionnaire was distributed to 81 consultant surgeons identified from the specialist register of the Irish Medical Council and practicing as general surgeons outside of specialist paediatric centres. A response rate of 83 % (67/81) was obtained. Of the 67 surgeons surveyed, 11 (16 %) had formal paediatric training. Sixty percent (40/67) of surgeons expressed a preference for the open technique. The median frequency of on-call rota was >1 in 5 (32/67) and only 3 % (2/67) claimed that the on-call commitment influenced decision-making regarding surgical approach. The average minimum age (9.3 years, range 1-14) and average minimum weight (25 kg, range 12-70) at which the operating surgeon would perform a laparoscopic appendicectomy were also recorded. Thirty percent (20/67) of consultant general surgeons had immediate access to specialist paediatric laparoscopic equipment. This study has shown wide variability amongst consultant general surgeons when considering open versus laparoscopic appendicectomy in children under 12 years. Restricted access to specialist paediatric laparoscopic equipment, combined with declining exposure to paediatric surgical training, may continue to limit the numbers of paediatric laparoscopic appendicectomies performed in the general setting.