Abstract
Background Protoceratops andrewsi (Neoceratopsia, Protoceratopsidae) is a well-known dinosaur from the Upper Cretaceous of Mongolia. Some previous workers hypothesized sexual dimorphism in the cranial shape of this taxon, using qualitative and quantitative observations. In particular, width and height of the frill as well as the development of a nasal horn have been hypothesized as potentially sexually dimorphic.Methodology/Principal FindingsHere, we reassess potential sexual dimorphism in skulls of Protoceratops andrewsi by applying two-dimensional geometric morphometrics to 29 skulls in lateral and dorsal views. Principal Component Analyses and nonparametric MANOVAs recover no clear separation between hypothetical “males” and “females” within the overall morphospace. Males and females thus possess similar overall cranial morphologies. No differences in size between “males” and “females” are recovered using nonparametric ANOVAs.Conclusions/SignificanceSexual dimorphism within Protoceratops andrewsi is not strongly supported by our results, as previously proposed by several authors. Anatomical traits such as height and width of the frill, and skull size thus may not be sexually dimorphic. Based on PCA for a data set focusing on the rostrum and associated ANOVA results, nasal horn height is the only feature with potential dimorphism. As a whole, most purported dimorphic variation is probably primarily the result of ontogenetic cranial shape changes as well as intraspecific cranial variation independent of sex.
Highlights
Sexual dimorphism is an expected product of sexual selection and represents an important factor in breeding success within many species [1,2,3]
Even in cases where sexual dimorphism seems plausible, limited sample sizes often prevent a rigorous test of the hypothesis
According to previous works [25], the most critical anatomical features for identifying sexual dimorphism within P. andrewsi are the postorbital width of the skull, width of the frill, nasal height of the skull, height of the frill, and length and width of external nares
Summary
Sexual dimorphism is an expected product of sexual selection and represents an important factor in breeding success within many species [1,2,3]. Morphology, behavior and size differences distinguish males and females in many extant and extinct animals [4,5,6,7,8,9,10,11,12,13,14,15,16,17,18]. Recognizing sexual dimorphism in extinct organisms presents special problems in that it can be difficult to distinguish sexual differences from ontogenetic or intraspecific ones. This issue has plagued attempts to recognize sexual dimorphism in non-avian dinosaurs. Width and height of the frill as well as the development of a nasal horn have been hypothesized as potentially sexually dimorphic
Talk to us
Join us for a 30 min session where you can share your feedback and ask us any queries you have