Male responses suggest both evolutionary conservation and rapid change in chemical cues of female widow spiders

Abstract

Understanding patterns of diversity in sexual signals can give insight into processes initiating, mediating or following from species diversification. Here we focus on female sex pheromones, which are widespread among animals, where some taxa show phylogenetic patterns of variation, but for others, ecological factors better explain pheromone diversity. Causes of differences in these patterns are unclear, and general insights require studying a broader range of taxa. Here we examined variation in the responses of male redback spiders, Latrodectus hasselti, to sex pheromones produced by three allopatric female congeners with different degrees of phylogenetic relatedness (from the same clade: Latrodectus mirabilis, Latrodectus hesperus; and from a different clade: Latrodectus geometricus) to infer pheromone divergence. We examined variation in male responses to conspecific and heterospecific females’ airborne and contact pheromones, which attract males and elicit courtship behaviour, respectively. We measured male courtship responses to extracted contact pheromones in isolation and male preferences in response to airborne pheromones and combined cues (pheromones, silk) in a two-choice maze. Male responses to airborne chemicals, contact chemicals and combined cues suggested variation in species specificity, with L. hasselti males showing strong discrimination against airborne pheromones of L. hesperus females (same clade), moderate evidence for discrimination based on contact cues of L. geometricus, but only when multiple sources of information were available (different clade), and no discrimination of L. mirabilis females (same clade) relative to conspecifics, regardless of the types of information available. Thus, male responses were not consistent with a phylogenetic pattern. Moreover, airborne pheromones can apparently diverge relatively rapidly, but airborne and contact pheromones may remain similar across long evolutionary timescales. We propose that differential responses to L. hesperus may arise from selection for population-level pheromone divergence within that species and that, in general, pheromones and male responses may be evolutionarily conserved across Latrodectus.