Magmatic Evolution of Zoned and Unzoned Ignimbrites: Evidence for a Complex Crustal Architecture Feeding four Rapid-sequence, Caldera-forming Eruptions in the San Juan Mountains, Colorado

Abstract

Abstract The last four caldera-forming ignimbrites in the central San Juan caldera cluster, Colorado, erupted 1400 km3 in ≤80 kyr and alternated between zoned crystal-poor rhyolite to crystal-rich dacite and unzoned, crystal-rich dacite. The zoned 150 km3 Rat Creek Tuff (26·91 Ma), unzoned 250 km3 Cebolla Creek Tuff, and zoned 500 km3 Nelson Mountain Tuff (26·90 Ma) formed the nested San Luis caldera complex with slightly offset calderas, and the unzoned 500 km3 Snowshoe Mountain Tuff (26·87 Ma) formed the Creede caldera to the south. The Rat Creek Tuff, Nelson Mountain Tuff, and Snowshoe Mountain Tuff have similar mineral assemblages of plagioclase, sanidine, quartz, biotite, hornblende, clinopyroxene, Fe–Ti oxides, and accessory zircon, titanite, and apatite. The Cebolla Creek Tuff differs from the other three ignimbrites with more abundant hornblende and a lack of quartz and sanidine. Trace element compositions of interstitial glass are unique to each ignimbrite, correlating with mineral assemblages and inferred crystallization depths. Glass, feldspar, hornblende, and clinopyroxene thermobarometry calculations provide evidence for vertically extensive crustal magma reservoirs with a common magmatic zone at ∼435–470 MPa (∼16–17 km) showing a transition into shallow pre-eruptive reservoirs between ∼110 and 340 MPa (∼4–13 km), similar to the estimated magma reservoir architecture of the Altiplano Puna Volcanic Complex. The upper portions of the eruptible parts of the magma reservoirs of the Rat Creek Tuff (215 ± 50 MPa, ∼810–820 °C), Cebolla Creek Tuff (340 ± 20 MPa, ∼860–880 °C), Nelson Mountain Tuff (215 ± 20 MPa, ∼745–800 °C), and Snowshoe Mountain Tuff (110 ± 40 MPa, 825 ± 10 °C) occupied shallow levels in the crust similar to other magma reservoirs of the central San Juan caldera cluster. Trace element modelling correlates with a deep crystallization signature in the unzoned Cebolla Creek Tuff and Snowshoe Mountain Tuff, typified by a flat trend in Ba versus Sr whole-rock and glass chemistry. The zoned Rat Creek Tuff and Nelson Mountain Tuff are typified by a steep trend in Ba versus Sr chemistry interpreted as a shallower crystallization signature. Similarly, the unzoned Cebolla Creek Tuff and Snowshoe Mountain Tuff have flatter slopes in FeO versus An space of plagioclase chemistry interpreted as more abundant deep plagioclase crystallization and a difficulty in physically mixing with Fe-rich mafic recharge magma owing to higher viscosity. The zoned Rat Creek Tuff and Nelson Mountain Tuff have higher slopes in FeO versus An space of plagioclase chemistry interpreted as more abundant shallow plagioclase crystallization and more feasible mixing with Fe-rich mafic recharge magma owing to lower viscosity. The eruption of the Rat Creek Tuff was probably triggered by mafic injection, but the other three ignimbrites lack mingling textures in pumice, suggesting that other mechanisms were important in causing such large eruptions. After a prolonged period of mantle-derived magma injection and crustal heating (∼25 000 km3 Conejos Formation erupted during ∼35–29 Ma), the San Juan magmatic body became a robust and versatile producer of diverse eruptible magmas in short time periods during its Oligocene ignimbrite flare-up.