M92 (NGC 6341) Is a Metal-complex Globular Cluster with an Atypical Primordial Population

Abstract

We present a multiple stellar population study of the metal-poor globular cluster (GC) M92 (NGC 6341), which is long known for the substantial metallicity dispersion, using our own photometric system. We find two groups with slightly different mean metallicities, the metal-poor (MP) stars with [Fe/H] hk = −2.412 ± 0.03 and the metal-rich (MR) ones with −2.282 ± 0.002. The MP constitutes about 23% of the total mass with a more central concentration. Our populational tagging based on the [C/Fe] ch and [N/Fe] nh provides the mean n(P):n(I):n(E) = 32.2:31.6:36.2 (±2.4), where P, I, and E denote the primordial, intermediate, and extreme populations, respectively. Our populational number ratio is consistent with those of others. However, the MP has a significantly different populational number ratio than the mean value, and the domination of the primordial population in the MP is consistent with observations of Galactic GCs that less massive GCs contain larger fractions of the primordial population. Structural and constituent differences between the MP and MR may indicate that M92 is a merger remnant in a dwarf galaxy environment, consistent with recent suggestions that M92 is a GC in a dwarf galaxy or a remnant nucleus of the progenitor galaxy. Discrepancy between our method and those widely used for the Hubble Space Telescope photometry exists in the primordial population. Significant magnesium and oxygen depletions of −0.8 and −0.3 dex, respectively, and helium enhancement of ΔY ≳ 0.03 are required to explain the presence of this abnormal primordial group. No clear explanation is available with limited information of detailed elemental abundances.