Lower sensitivity of cyprinid fishes to three acetylcholinesterase inhibitor pesticides: an evaluation based on no-effect concentrations

Abstract

Researchers have suggested that cyprinid fishes are less sensitive to chemical stress than comparable fish families, yet few empirically based evaluations of this hypothesis have been conducted. In this study, we developed a generalized linear mixed model in which the no-effect concentrations (NECs; threshold concentration below which no effect on survival is predicted during prolonged exposure) of 29 fish species from 13 families exposed to an acetylcholinesterase inhibitor pesticide (carbaryl, chlorpyrifos, or malathion) were used as the response variable. The corresponding specific somatic maintenance (SSM) rates, as a size-independent proxy for fish metabolism and a categorical variable regarding whether the species is a cyprinid, were used as the predictor variables. We included SSM rates in the analysis because previous work demonstrated that they are negatively correlated with NECs. Our results indicate that the NECs for cyprinid fishes were significantly higher than those for other fishes, suggesting that cyprinids are indeed less sensitive to the three studied pesticides. Although the SSM rates were negatively related with the NECs, the actual relationship between the two was not clear, implying that the importance of SSM rates may depend on the taxonomic group tested.