Low vegetation recovery after short-term cattle exclusion on Robinson Crusoe Island

Abstract

Livestock browsing and grazing are considered serious threats to the conservation of the Juan Fernandez Islands’ flora, Chile. Nowadays the elimination of grazing by cattle is very difficult. In order to prevent the␣entrance of cattle into the native forests, an 8.3 km-long fence was established on the main island (Robinson Crusoe). The response of the vegetation was evaluated during 27 months of exclusion. The changes in abundances and composition of species were monitored in 12 permanent plots, each of 25 m2, located in ungrazed and grazed areas. We expected an increase in plant height and total ground cover in the ungrazed area, and also a directional compositional change towards forest species. We found five different patterns of variation or non-variation for the 22 species observed: (i) one species (Acaena argentea) diminished in abundance in the ungrazed area; (ii) another one (Conium maculatum) increased in the ungrazed area; (iii) one species (Vulpia bromoides) increased in the grazing area; and some species displayed no net variation, but they showed (iv) a nearly constant occurrence, or (v) they appeared and disappeared sporadically. Contrary to our hypothesis, the vegetation showed no net differences in cover on both sides of the fence. As expected, plant height increased in the ungrazed area. In this area, we detected no noteworthy changes in floristic composition towards forest species. On the contrary, four new pastureland species appeared outside of the exclusion area during the last year of evaluation. Other ungrazed sectors of the island showed qualitative differences from grazed sectors, such as major height and density of plants, and lower intensity of browsing, grazing, and trampling, attributable to a reduction of herbivorous pressure. The modest responses reported in this study could be related to the short lapse of time since the exclusion, soil compaction, overgrowth by a single species (A. argentea), great seasonal variations in different species’ abundances, the reduction in the number of cattle grazing the area previous to the fence’s installation, and persistent herbivory by rabbits (Oryctolagus cuniculus L.). We conclude that the effect of grazing by cattle is␣less than expected, and that there are other factors that delay the recovery of the Juan Fernandez pasturelands.