Low frequency of resistance to thiophanate-methyl in Monilinia fructicola populations from southeastern United States peach orchards

Abstract

Methyl benzimidazole carbamate (MBC) fungicides were once widely used for brown rot (Monilinia fructicola) control of peach (Prunus persica (L.) Batsch) in the southeastern US, but their use was substantially reduced and often eliminated due to widespread resistance. In this study, 233 M. fructicola isolates were collected from major peach production areas in Alabama, Georgia, and South Carolina, and sensitivity to thiophanate-methyl was examined. Isolates were also collected from one organic and two experimental peach orchards. A discriminatory dose of 1 μg/ml was used to distinguish sensitive (S) and moderately sensitive (S-LR) isolates from low resistant phenotypes, while 50 and 500 μg/ml thiophanate-methyl concentrations were used to determine high resistant (HR) phenotypes. Sequence analyses were performed to identify mutations in the β-tubulin target gene and detached fruit assays were performed to determine the efficacy of a commercial product against isolates representing each phenotype. Results indicated 55.7%, 63.5%, and 75.9% of isolates from Alabama, Georgia, and South Carolina, respectively, were S to thiophanate-methyl; 44.3%, 36.5%, and 21.4% were S-LR; no isolates were LR; and only 3 isolates (1.3%) from South Carolina were HR. No mutations in S or S-LR isolates were found, but HR isolates revealed the E198A mutation, an amino acid change of glutamic acid to alanine conferring high resistance. The high label rate of a commercial product containing thiophanate-methyl controlled brown rot caused by S and S-LR isolates in detached fruit studies but was ineffective against HR isolates. The combinations of thiophanate-methyl with azoxystrobin or isofetamid, when mixed together and applied in an experimental orchard 14 days preharvest, significantly reduced brown rot incidence on pre and postharvest commercially ripe fruit and efficacy was comparable to that of a grower standard fungicide. These results indicate that thiophanate-methyl may again be useful to peach growers in the southeastern US for brown rot and fungicide resistance management.