Long-term success in percutaneous valve commissurotomy – is Wilkins score over 9 a definitive limit?

Abstract

Abstract Background Percutaneous valve commissurotomy (PMC) is an established treatment in patients with significative mitral stenosis (MS). Although rheumatic MS incidence has decreased in the last century, it remains a prevalent pathology worldwide. The Wilkins score (WS) is a reference in echocardiographic assessment of MS; a score ≤8 is considered a predictor of treatment success and score between 9 and 11 is a “grey zone” (WGZ) in which doubts persists regarding PMC success. Purpose To evaluate the early and long-term results of PMC in patients with rheumatic MS and to compare long-term events between patients with WS ≤8 and patients in WGZ. Methods We retrospectively analysed all patients between 1991 and 2008 with significative rheumatic MS undergoing PMC. Data were collected at baseline and during long-term follow-up. M ACE was defined as a composite of all-cause mortality, mitral valve re-intervention or cardiovascular hospitalization. Results In our cohort, 124 patients were included. Most were female (87%), mean age at the time of repair was 46±11 year-old and mean follow-up was 20±6 years. Before the procedure, 81% had WS ≤8 and 19% were in WGZ. Both groups had similar baseline characteristics, namely age at first intervention, NYHA class and follow-up time. All patients had preserved biventricular systolic function, 83% presented PH, mean transvalvular gradient (TVG) and mitral valve area (MVA) were 12.8 mmHg and 1.0 cm2, respectively. Most of the procedures were successful (91%) and without complications (94%). Mean MVA improvement was similar in both groups [0.9 cm2 in WS ≤8 and 0.8 cm2 in WGZ, t(102)=0.173, p=0.863]; there was also no significative difference in TVG and PASP reduction after PMC. During long-term follow-up, re-intervention and mortality occurred in 40% and 23% in WS ≤8 and in 50% and 29% in WGZ, respectively, and none of these differences was statistically significant (p=0.389 and p=0.544, respectively). Concerning time-to-event analysis, approximately 80% of patients kept uneventful and >90% alive after 10 years in both groups and no significant difference in M ACE events and all-cause mortality between WS ≤8 and WGZ was observed (Log Rank, p=0,419 and p=0.950, respectively). Conclusion PMC was safe and effective in clinically significant rheumatic MS in both WS ≤8 and WS 9–11, with similar MVA improvement. After 10 years, approximately 80% of patients were MACE-free and >90% alive in both groups. There was no difference in all-cause mortality and in a composite of all-cause death, mitral valve re-intervention or cardiovascular hospitalization concerning WS groups. Funding Acknowledgement Type of funding sources: None.