Long-term Follow-up Study for Fractured and Non-Fractured Hand Enchondromas Treated by Sole Curettage

Abstract

Background: Enchondromas are the most common primary tumors in the small tubular bones of the hand and fractures are often the result of thinned cortical bone. The main question was whether fractured enchondromas influence the long-term clinical and radiological outcome. Methods: Between 2000 and 2019, 57 patients with previously treated fractured (group I) and non-fractured (group II) hand enchondromas (34 female, 23 male, mean age was 39.4 years, ± 13.7) were evaluated for clinical and radiological treatment outcomes. SF-36 and DASH questionnaires as well as patient reported experience measures were used to assess subjective health outcomes. Subsequently, 43 patients underwent clinical and radiological follow-ups. Comparative evaluation of objective treatment outcomes in both groups was conducted in terms of hand functionality, perioperative complications, recurrence rates, and osteogenesis. Results: Almost half the patients suffered enchondromas with fractures (49.1%, n=28). Two patients received additional k-wire-stabilization due to intraoperative instability. Defect resolution could be reached in 97.7% (n=42) of all cases. No recurrence of enchondroma was observed. Groups were equal regarding radiological and clinical outcomes. The patient reported experiences were predominantly positive (86%), both cohorts had good to very good results with a DASH mean score of 4 (±6.3). The SF-36 demonstrated a return to normal quality of life in both groups. Mean follow-up time was 7.78 years (±4.8). Conclusions: Sole curettage of enchondromas yields effective outcomes with good to excellent results regardless of the presence of a fracture. Long-term radiological follow-up is not required until symptomatic recurrence. .