Logging and soil disturbance in southeast British Columbia

Abstract

The purpose of this study was to document and to analyze extent, type, and degree of soil disturbance on ground-skidded and cable-yarded cutovers. The primary hypothesis was that ground skidding on steep, high elevation sites generates more soil disturbance than cable yarding. Thirty-one cutovers were surveyed in the Nelson Forest Region: 25 logged by ground skidding and 6 by cable yarding. Three replications were obtained for each season – slope class on ground-skidded sites. Cable-logged areas were also replicated three times, but only for season. Elevations of the cutovers ranged from 910 to 1970 m with an average of 1360 m. Slope steepness on cutovers ranged from 5 to 74%. Soil disturbance was significantly greater on ground-skidded than on cable-yarded cutovers, averaging 40–45% vs. 22–30%, respectively, regardless of season. Differences in soil disturbance between logging methods by season were small and not significant. Average soil disturbances for summer cable yarding and ground skidding were 30 and 45%, respectively, compared with 22 and 40% for winter operations. Analysis of soil disturbance by source revealed skidroads as the major cause of disturbance on ground-skidded cutovers, regardless of season. The primary source of disturbance on cable-yarded areas was yarding in the summer and haul roads in the winter. Ground skidding also caused more deep to very deep disturbance, averaging 30% in winter and 35% in summer compared with 18 and 14% on cable-yarded sites. For both methods deep and very deep disturbance were most common accounting for 75–80% of total disturbance. Extent of soil disturbance and slope steepness were not significantly related. The high variability in soil disturbance noted in this study was similar to other surveys. Most studies have attempted to associate such variation with major environmental factors but with little success. To fully explain soil disturbance, operational factors such as planning and layout of logging must be considered.