Lobectomy for Suspected Lung Cancer Without Prior Diagnosis

Abstract

BackgroundWe describe use, patients, and outcome of diagnostic lobectomy for suspected lung cancer without pathologic confirmation. MethodsA retrospective review of consecutive lobectomy or bilobectomy for suspected or confirmed primary pulmonary malignancy was conducted using our participant’s sample of The Society of Thoracic Surgeons database. Surgeons performed lobectomy based on clinical diagnosis or confirmation on a biopsy specimen. Lung cancer confirmed by biopsy specimen was compared with cases clinically suspected. Univariate and multivariate analyses identified variables associated with lobectomy without biopsy specimen confirmation. ResultsAmong 2651 lobectomies performed between 2006 and 2019 in 2617 patients, lung cancer was confirmed by preoperative biopsy specimen in 51.6% (1368 of 2651) or was clinically suspected before the operation in 48.4% (1283 of 2651). The intraoperative biopsy specimen in 585 of 1283 cases (45.6%) proved lung cancer before lobectomy, whereas lobectomy proceeded in 698 cases (54.4%) without a diagnosis. Final pathology proved lung cancer in 90% (628 of 698) without a diagnosis before lobectomy and nonmalignant disease in 10% (70 of 698). Nonneoplastic pathology included granulomas (30 of 70 [43%]), pneumonia (12 of 70 [17%]), bronchiectasis (7 of 70 [10%]), and other lesions (21 of 70 [30%]). Operative mortality was 0.94% (25 of 2651) for the cohort and 1.0% (7 of 698) for diagnostic lobectomy only. Multivariate analysis identified patient age, type of lobectomy (right middle lobe), and the intermediate study tercile as associated with diagnostic lobectomy. ConclusionsLobectomy for suspected lung cancer without diagnosis is common, represents practice variation, and infrequently (10% diagnostic, 2.6% all lobectomies) removes nonmalignant disease. Tissue confirmation before lobectomy is preferred, particularly when operative risk is increased. Diagnostic lobectomy is acceptable in carefully selected patients and lesions.