Living mulches reduce natural enemies when combined with frequent pesticide applications

Abstract

Agricultural intensification with frequent pesticide applications often diminishes biological control services delivered by beneficial insects. However, re-integrating diverse and structurally complex non-crop habitat may mitigate negative effects by providing refugia to natural enemies, enabling rapid recolonization of pesticide-treated crops. This study examines the compatibility of chemical control with non-crop habitat management by manipulating pesticide treatments and living mulches between rows of zucchini crops in four replicated experiments across the Southeastern United States. The hypothesis was that living mulches and pesticide applications would each negatively impact pests and have interactive effects on predatory insects, with negative pesticide effects being attenuated in plots with untreated living mulches serving as refugia for predators between crop rows. Instead, combining living mulches with pesticide applications reduced natural enemy densities, relative to bare plots. Pesticide applications had no effect on spotted and striped cucumber beetle pests, while living mulches directly reduced them by 25%. Conversely, pesticide applications reduced squash bug pressure by 50%, while living mulches had no effect. Although crops were grown in plastic mulch to protect them from competition, living mulches reduced zucchini yields by 54% at sites where living mulches were less-managed. Alternatively, living mulches had more neutral effects on yields at sites where mulches were mowed monthly, suggesting that living mulches require management to minimize competition with crops. These results suggest that the grass-dominated living mulches tested in this study did little to harmonize chemical and biological control. While non-crop plant diversity has clear benefits for natural pest suppression in many systems, these benefits cannot be generalized across all plant and insect taxa. Future efforts to fine-tune management of non-crop habitat within fields will be strengthened by consideration of traits of key pests and their specific responses to both pesticide applications and plant diversity.