Littoral Fish Community Response to Smallmouth Bass Removal from an Adirondack Lake

Abstract

AbstractLarge‐scale observational studies in eastern Canada and the northeastern USA have concluded that introduced littoral predators are responsible for reductions in native fish diversity and abundance. To determine whether nonnative predator removal could increase native littoral fish abundance, we removed 47,682 smallmouth bass Micropterus dolomieu from a 271‐ha Adirondack lake during a 6‐year period. Two years after removal began, habitat‐stratified snorkel surveys indicated a greater than 90% reduction in smallmouth bass abundance. The relative abundances of six native littoral species increased (4‐90 times preremoval abundances) within 2 years of smallmouth bass removal. Decreased relative predation risk during the experiment reflected the reduction in littoral predators and identified seasonal differences in nearshore predation risk. The smallmouth bass population was resilient to removal, producing strong year‐classes throughout the experiment. Mechanical removal was successful at decreasing smallmouth bass abundance and increasing native fish abundance, but removal must be conducted on a yearly basis to maintain low smallmouth bass population abundance. Our results provide experimental evidence regarding the need to prevent littoral predator introductions in Adirondack waters and offer support for nonnative control wherever native fish species conservation is a management priority.