Limiting regimes of turbulent horizontal convection. Part 1. Intermediate and low Prandtl numbers

Abstract

We report the existence of two new limiting turbulent regimes in horizontal convection (HC) using direct numerical simulations at intermediate to low Prandtl numbers. In our simulations, the flow is driven by a step-wise buoyancy profile imposed at the surface, with free-slip, no-flux conditions along all other boundaries, except along the spanwise direction, where periodicity is assumed. The flow is shown to transition to turbulence in the plume and the core, modifying the rate of heat and momentum transport. These transitions set a sequence of scaling laws that combine theoretical arguments from Shishkina, Grossmann and Lohse (SGL) and Hughes, Griffiths, Mullarney and Peterson (HGMP). The parameter range extends through Rayleigh numbers in the range [ $6.4\times 10^5, 1.92\times 10^{15}$ ] and Prandtl numbers in the range [ $2\times 10^{-3},2$ ]. At low Prandtl numbers and intermediate Rayleigh numbers, a core-driven regime is shown to follow a Nusselt-number scaling with $Ra^{1/6}Pr^{7/24}$ . For Rayleigh numbers larger than $10^{14}$ , the Nusselt number scales with $Ra^{0.225}Pr^{0.417}$ . For these particular regimes, the Reynolds number is found to scale as $Ra^{2/5}Pr^{-3/5}$ for the low-Prandtl-number regime and $Ra^{1/3}Pr^{1}$ for Rayleigh numbers larger than $10^{14}$ . These results embed the HGMP model in the SGL theory and extend the known regime diagram of HC at high Rayleigh numbers. In particular, we show that HC and Rayleigh–Bénard share similar turbulent characteristics at low Prandtl numbers, where HC is shown to be ruled by its core dynamics and turbulent boundary layers. This new scenario confirms that fully turbulent HC enhances the transport of heat and momentum with respect to previously reported regimes at high Rayleigh numbers. This work provides new insights into the applicability of HC for geophysical flows such as overturning circulations found in the atmosphere, the oceans, and flows near the Earth's inner core.