Limiting Factors for Indication of Hip and Knee Arthroplasty in Chile: The International Perception of Risk Initiative

Abstract

BackgroundAn aging population with a resultant higher incidence of osteoarthritis have increased the need for total hip (THA) and knee arthroplasty (TKA) worldwide. The purpose of this study was to explore what medical and social risk factors are considered relevant by Chilean orthopaedic surgeons in decisions regarding indications for THA or TKA. MethodsAn anonymous survey was sent to 165 hip and knee arthroplasty surgeons who were members of the Chilean Orthopedics and Traumatology Society. From a total of 165 surgeons, 128 (78%) completed the survey. The questionnaire included demographic data, place of work, and inquired about medical and socioeconomic factors that could affect surgical indications. ResultsFactors that limited indications for elective THA/TKA included body mass index (81%), elevated hemoglobin A1c (92%), lack of social support network (58%), and low socioeconomic status (40%). Most respondents made decisions based on personal experience or literature review rather than hospital or departmental pressures. Of the respondents, 64% believe that some patient populations would benefit from better care if payment systems adjusted for their socioeconomic risk factors. ConclusionIn Chile, limitations regarding the indication for THA/TKA are most influenced by the presence of modifiable medical risk factors such as obesity, uncompensated diabetes, or malnutrition. We believe that the reason surgeons limit surgeries for such individuals is to promote better clinical outcomes, and not in response to pressure from paying entities. However, low socioeconomic status was perceived to impair the ability to achieve good clinical outcomes by 40% of the surgeons.