Limitations to growth of microorganisms on Uranus, Neptune, and Titan

Abstract

We have examined a wide range of physical, chemical, and thermal models of the atmosphere of Uranus. In that model, which we believe maximizes favorable conditions for the support of life [Weidenschilling and Lewis, Icarus 20, 465–476 (1973)], we find the probability of growth of a contaminant terrestrial microorganisms to be nil. If, as is likely, conditions are even more extreme on Neptune, the probability of contamination of both of the outer planets Uranus and Neptune is nil. The Wiedenschilling and Lewis model guarantees the presence of water droplets through the temperature range 0 to 100°C; other published models add water liquid at higher temperatures or fail to provide liquid water at all within this temperature range. In this model the heavy elements (C, N, O, etc.) are enhanced in Uranus by a factor sufficient to form a deep massive cloud layer of aqueous ammonia solution droplets. We can estimate the probability of growth with respect to the following factors: the presence of stable liquid water, convection of parcels of atmosphere to lethally hot depths, solar energy sources reaching the water layer, organic molecular production by solar ultraviolet light, ammonia concentration at the water cloud level, ionic species distribution, and concentrations at the water cloud level. The evaluation of these factors suggests that most terrestrial life as we know it would be excluded on the basis of any one of them. We know of no organism that would be adapted to all the stringent Uranus conditions simultaneously. The discovery of even a single species of Earth organism that can survive or grow under allowable outer planetary conditions would establish new principles in biology. Titan, the methane-rich moon of Saturn, may be more hospitable for terrestrial organisms than any of the other objects of the outer solar system. Even there we see formidable barriers to the growth of an Earth organism in Titan's atmosphere. We recognize that revision of our views concerning Titan must occur as more is learned about this satellite. We advocate the abandonment, in principle, of the probabilistic approach to the estimation of growth of terrestrial organisms on spacecraft, planets, and satellites in the solar system. We do not support an approach which estimates probabilities of qualitatively unknown phenomena. We recommend a strategy which involves identification and intensive study of those organisms most likely to thrive under known conditions for each of the planets respectively. (Unknown environmental conditions may be allowed to vary optimally.) Some explicit areas for Earth-based experimentation are indicated.