Learning to teach at a norm-critical clinical learning centre: A Phenomenographic study

Abstract

BackgroundCampus-based clinical learning centres are used for practice and learning in nursing students' education and can be arenas in which to enhance students' awareness and competence in social justice issues. Norm-critical approaches can be used as pedagogical tools in these centres to prepare students for hands-on caring situations in which social norms can bias the outcome. ObjectivesTo describe nursing teachers' conceptions of learning norm-critical approaches and implementing them in a clinical training centre. Setting and participantsThe study is based on interviews with 10 teachers at a Swedish university college. MethodsThe data was analysed using a phenomenographic approach. ResultsFive categories of description emerged in the analysis that described conceptions related to norm-critical approaches. These categories were: personally developing and meaningful; easily integrated with established nursing concepts; highlighting surrounding power; something to lean on when letting students take the first steps in norm-critical initiatives; and helping implementation in teaching and education. ConclusionsTeachers who are facing the task of providing norm-critical, practical education to nursing students in campus-based clinical learning environments are ambivalent towards the core principles of norm criticism, which they conceive as natural and provoking, at the same time. We therefore need to un-dramatise norm criticism and better prepare teachers in how to use it. Teachers would benefit from follow-up activities and formal collaborations regarding norm-critical teaching, so that they are given context to discuss, reflect, and learn from each other.