Abstract

Flood and water management governance may be enhanced through partnership working, intra- and cross-organisational collaborations, and wide stakeholder participation. Nonetheless, barriers associated with ineffective communication, fragmented responsibilities and ‘siloed thinking’ restrict open dialogue and discussion. The Learning and Action Alliance (LAA) framework may help overcome these barriers by enabling effective engagement through social learning, and facilitating targeted actions needed to deliver innovative solutions to environmental problems. By increasing the adaptive capacity of decision-makers and participants, social learning through LAAs may lead to concerted action and sustained processes of behavioural change. In this paper, we evaluate the LAA framework as a catalyst for change that supports collaborative working and facilitates transition to more sustainable flood risk management. We use a case study in Newcastle-upon-Tyne, UK, to demonstrate how the LAA framework brought together disparate City stakeholders to co-produce new knowledge, negotiate innovative actions and, ultimately, work towards implementing a new vision for sustainable urban flood risk management. The shared vision of Newcastle as a ‘Blue-Green City’ that emerged is founded on a strong platform for social learning which increased organisations’ and individuals’ capacities to manage differences in perspectives and behaviours, reframe knowledge, and make collective decisions based on negotiation and conflict resolution. Broad recommendations based on lessons learned from the Newcastle LAA are presented to aid other cities and regions in establishing and running social learning platforms.

Highlights

  • In England and Wales, annual expected damages due to flooding exceed £1 billion (Environment Agency, 2014) and are predicted to rise due to projected increases in the frequency, intensity and magnitude of storm events (Ramsbottom et al, 2012)

  • One Newcastle Learning and Action Alliance (LAA) member noted the importance of collaborative working and the need to include new knowledge to deliver multifunctional infrastructure; “there probably was, more or less, the sort of expertise [in Newcastle City Council] to run the flood risk management side, but perhaps less so in that sort of multidisciplinary approach that you need to take to Sustainable Drainage Systems (SuDS)⋯there's a real need to bring in perhaps landscape architecture and ecologists, and other public engineers and planners” (Respondent #13, data presented in O’Donnell et al, 2017b)

  • Collaborative working and stakeholder participation are frequently recommended as mechanisms to enhance flood and water management decision-making

Read more

Summary

Introduction

In England and Wales, annual expected damages due to flooding exceed £1 billion (Environment Agency, 2014) and are predicted to rise due to projected increases in the frequency, intensity and magnitude of storm events (Ramsbottom et al, 2012). Experience gained in pioneering cities such as Portland, Oregon, demonstrates that implementing transformative change and creating BGI requires stakeholders to develop long-term, shared visions for achieving urban flood resilience, which requires collaboration between multiple organisations and branches of city government and administration (Thorne et al, 2015). Social learning, where actors interact to develop alternative perspectives (whether at the individual or group level) on societal issues and collectively enable change (Bos et al, 2013), is a key component of sustainable water management It emphasises development of adaptive cross-sectoral capacities and co-production of knowledge to respond to dynamic social-ecological systems (Pahl-Wostl et al, 2008). Lessons learned from the Newcastle LAA are summarised and recommendations for enhancing social learning through LAAs are proposed

Social learning through LAAs
Benefits of social learning in transformative thinking
The LAA framework
Case study: the Newcastle LAA
Procedural steps and phases
Developing a shared vision and the Newcastle declaration
Discussion
Social learning within the Newcastle LAA
Findings
Recommendations
Conclusion
Full Text
Published version (Free)

Talk to us

Join us for a 30 min session where you can share your feedback and ask us any queries you have

Schedule a call