Landscape change with agricultural intensification in a rural watershed, southwestern Ohio, U.S.A.

Abstract

Specialized cash grain production, emergent in the midwestern United States during the post-WWII era, typifies the Upper Four Mile Creek watershed in southwestern Ohio. This style of agriculture intensifies cropland use, with consequent increases in soil erosion and stream sedimentation - a serious problem in the lower reservoir, Acton Lake. Agricultural statistics and aerial photographs compiled between 1934 and 1984 were used to quantify agricultural dynamics and landscape change in the watershed, including land-use apportionment, diversity, and the structural configuration of forest, woodland, and old-field/brushland patches and corridors. A questionnaire sent to all land owners in the basin documented farm-level characteristics and factors that influence management decisions. Crop diversity (H′) in Preble County, Ohio decreased from 1.42 in 1934 to 1.17 in 1982, as corn and soybeans dominated the landscape mosaic. Yields rose, but net profits were reduced by declining prices per bushel and increases in fertilizer and petroleum-based subsidies. Landuse diversity in the county also declined (H′ = 1.37 in 1934 tot 0.80 in 1982) in response to cropland expansion, whereas forest land in the watershed increased from 1605 to 2603 ha. Fragmentation declined and the landscape became polarized after 1956, with a concentration of agricultural patches in the upper watershed and forest-patch coalescence in stream gullies and state park land in the lower watershed. The questionnaire (~ 29% return) further supported, at the farm-level, observed regional trends toward expansion (farm coalescence and lease contracts) and specialization (conversion toward corn and soybeans). The most important factors influencing farm size and management were better equipment and family traditions. Thus, cultural and technological factors that operate at the farm-level, coupled with meso-scale variation in the physical conditions of a catchment basin, tend to influence landscape-level patterns more than regional socioeconomics and governmental policies.