Laboratory evaluation of three dual rapid diagnostic tests for HIV and syphilis in China and Nigeria

Abstract

ObjectiveTo determine the laboratory-based performance and operational characteristics of three dual rapid diagnostic tests (RDTs) for testing HIV and syphilis. MethodsThree dual RDTs (SD Bioline, Chembio, and MedMira) were evaluated using 1514 serum specimens archived at laboratories or collected from clinics in China and Nigeria to determine sensitivity and specificity, with 95% confidence intervals. Concordance of testing results read by two technicians, stability of testing results read at two time points, and test operation characteristics were also assessed. ResultsAll three of the evaluated RDTs gave excellent performance with a combined sensitivity ranging from 99.0%–99.6% for HIV and 98.3%–99.0% for syphilis, and a combined specificity ranging from 97.9%–99.0% for HIV and 97.2%–99.6% for syphilis. Concordance of testing results between two technicians and stability of testing results read within and one hour past the recommended reading period showed excellent agreement, with Kappa greater than or equal to 0.98. ConclusionsAll the tests were found to be very or fairly easy to use and easy to interpret the results. Further evaluations of these dual RDTs with whole blood in field settings, and more studies on the implication of introduction of these tests in HIV and syphilis control programs are needed.