Abstract
The key task of my text is the justification of the use of on phenomenological model of the subject designated as a “my pain and my love”. First, such subject is seen as an alternative to the transcendental subject of the classical philosophy, which is characterized first of all as a rational subject. This rational subject is capable to give himself a generally valid rule of knowledge and action. Second, the phenomenological understanding of the subject represents a certain version of the “false consciousness”, which was developed from the “masters of the suspicion” (Marx, Freud, Nietzsche). Philosophy of the “masters” was intended to criticize the autonomy and absolutely self-determination of the rational subject and show the different forms of the conditionality on the Reason. Thirdly, the phenomenological understanding of the subject is a response to the different forms of philosophical reduction of subjectivity and self-consciousness. This response is developed in this text as a discussion with Manfred Frank. The phenomenological subject is the embodied or bodily subject. This embodiment has three dimensions (B. Waldenfels): World-relation (Weltbezug), Self-relation (Selbstbezug) and Others-relation (Fremdbezug). These dimensions allow to speak about the bodily subject as a Self, which is interpreted as my embodiment to the Other. “The I as my pain and my love” is a metaphor of this form of the Self, which means, that self-comprehension originates in the feeling of the pain and of the love, that is, in the certain experience of own body and in the act of love for this concrete Other. Such experience can be designated as a process of identification. The bodily subject as my embodiment to the Other is strongly connected with different praxis of the “socialization of the body”, which are in need of the philosophical analyses and criticism. Phenomenology proposes its own direction of criticism, which intends to justify that difference of the social and cultural praxis themselves is based on the originality of my embodiment to the Other and not vice versa. Thus the explication of the originality of the Self must be connected with the analyses and criticism of the “socialization of the body”, which includes a new non-classical ethical dimension.
Highlights
eHOMeHOllOZU'teCICUU cy6be1Cm R8ARemca cy6be1CmOM 8011/IOU{eHHblM, o U.MeHHO, meAeCHblM. llpu 3moM meAecHocmb U.Meem mpu p08HoucxoiJHwc U3MepeHUR: omHeceHHOCmb " Mupy (We/tbezug), omHeceHHocmb "ce6e (Se/bstbezug) u omHeceHHocmb "'tyxiJoMy (Fremdbezug)
Mo:xa10 .D;aJire CK838Tb, qro HMCHHO me11eCHOCmb KaK C03HaHHe-B-TeJie H jlBJijlC'fCjl HHTCHU:HOHaJibHOit,TaK KaK HMCH HO H8 qyBCTBCHHOM ypOBHe (CI0.!1;8 OTHOCHTCjl H ow.yw:eHHe,sentir H sensation,H BOCrrpmrm:e, perception) HCXO.D;HblM H C8MblM llOJIHblM o6p830M MHe .D;aHbl rrpe,D;MeThl: KaK BH.D;HMblC H 0Cjl38CMble,OOOHjlCMble H CJiblum:Mble H T.,D;.3 B TaKOM CJiyą8e,MblUJJumue rrpe.D;MeTa jlBJijlC'fCjl p83HOBH.D;HOCTblO ero qYBCTBCHHO-TeJICCHoro llOJiaraHHjl B K8'1CCTBC 'lpaHCU:CH.D;HpOBaHHjl 3TOf0 llOJiaraHHjl: B K8'1CCTBe BblX0.!1;8 38 rrpe .D;CJibl KOHKPeTHOit cuzyaųHH BH.D;CHHjl,0Cj138HHjl, 060Hjlffffjl rrpe,nMeTa H rrpoen:upoBaHHjl CMblCJI8 31'0it cuzyan:uu, KOTūpbiit MepJio IloHm o603H8'18eT «Bbip83HTCJihHbIM CMbic JIOM», H8 BCjlKYJO cuzyaųHIO - «llpe.D;Memblit CMbICJI» HJIH CMblCJI KaK TaKOBOit. qYBCTB8 31'0 Me.D;H8TūpbI; Bernu Bcer,n8 yxe ,n8HbI B 'IYBCTBax - KOHKPCTHbIX qyBCTBCHHbIX CH'IY8U:Hil. IlpH 3TOM B CHJIY oco6oro,HCXO.D;HOfO H llOCT0jlfff f0f0 B3aHMO,D;eitCTBHjl 'IYBCTB, HJIH CHHCCTC3HH,Mbl HMeeM .D;eJIO e U:eJibIM - rryCTb H O'IKpbIThlM - rrpe.D;MeTa H MMp8,8 He OT,Il;eJihHO CO CJiblum:MbIM, OT.D;eJihHO C BH.!l;HMbIM H T.,D;.
H3 Hee eJie,IJ;yeT, 'ITO 06m;eCTBo H KYJib1)'pa HMeIOT B eBOeM 6araxe IlOJIHblii Ha6op H,IJ;eHTHąHoeTeii H npoeTo npe,ll;JaraIOT,HJIH ,ll;IDKe HaBjl3blBaIOT HX MHe B ųeJI.ffX eBoero eo6CTBeHHoro eaMoeoxpaHeHHjl. B TilKOM ae, HeB03MO:lKHbIM eTilHOBHTCjl HenOHHMaHHe JI,IO lMl;b H ,IJ;pyr ,IJ;pyra: KOJib eKopo Bee 3TH H.n;eHmąHoem yxe .n;o roro eomaeo BaHbl B Me,IJ;HYMe KYJibTYPbl H o6m;eCTBa. Ha 3TO MO:lKHO HaiiTH TilKHe OTBeTbl: H,IJ;eHmą HOeTH pa3,IJ;eJieHbl ,IJ;pyr OT ,IJ;pyra pa3pb1BaMH,B pe3yJibTilTe,)J;pyroii He IlOCTIDKHM,ero MO:lKHO TOJibKO npHeBOHTb, eoBepWHB Ha.n; HHM HaeHJIHe. H 3.n;eeb oTąaeTH noeTeTpyK TYPMHeTbl npaBbl: He e HaeHJIHeM JIH HMeeM Mbl .n;eJio B 60JibWeii Mepe, He OT OTCYTCTBHjl JIH B3aHMonoHHMaHHjl eTpa,IJ;aeM?
Summary
eHOMeHOllOZU'teCICUU cy6be1Cm R8ARemca cy6be1CmOM 8011/IOU{eHHblM, o U.MeHHO, meAeCHblM. llpu 3moM meAecHocmb U.Meem mpu p08HoucxoiJHwc U3MepeHUR: omHeceHHOCmb " Mupy (We/tbezug), omHeceHHocmb "ce6e (Se/bstbezug) u omHeceHHocmb "'tyxiJoMy (Fremdbezug)
Talk to us
Join us for a 30 min session where you can share your feedback and ask us any queries you have