Kidneys from pediatric donors: risk versus benefit

Abstract

We encountered four adult patients who received renal transplants from young children < 36 months of age, each of whom developed severe hypertension, heavy proteinuria, and progressive renal failure. Biopsies disclosed glomerular sclerosis with crescents in three patients and mesangial expansion in one. We thus analyzed our experience with 74 adults who received grafts from donors < or = 10 years of age and compared the results to those of 804 patients who were transplanted with kidneys from donors > 10 years of age. A Kaplan-Meier analysis revealed that graft survival was significantly worse in patients receiving grafts from younger, compared to older donors. This difference was apparent in patients treated either with or without cyclosporine. A subanalysis comparing patients with donor grafts aged < or = 5 or 6-10 years revealed a further adverse age-related effect. Renal artery thrombosis and recurrent or de novo biopsy-proven glomerulonephritis were more common in patients receiving grafts from younger donors, while graft failure from rejection actually appeared less common. We conclude that severe hypertension and resultant glomerular hyperperfusion promoted glomerulosclerosis and crescent formation in our patients. Our results have caused us to pursue a more conservative approach towards transplanting grafts from donors aged < or = 10 years into adult recipients.