Karl Abraham’s Revolution of 1916: from Sensual Sucking to the Oralaggressive Wish of Destruction

Abstract

The author argues that “The First Pregenital Stage of the Libido” (Abraham 1916–1917) expounds a new conception of orality, i.e., of purposeful oral aggression directed against an object during the first stage of psychic development. This conception is shown to be contrary to Freud’s view of orality as elaborated in Three Essays on the Theory of Sexuality (1905), as well as in other writings of late 1914 and 1915. Abraham’s conception ignores fundamental dimensions of Freud’s thinking during these years, namely, the difference between autoerotism/narcissism and object love, on the one hand, and also between the leading role of sexuality and the secondary role of aggression, on the other. Thus, Abraham’s thinking represents a basic theoretical change that had far-reaching consequences for psychoanalytic practice.