Isotopic study of honey documents widespread plant uptake of old carbon in North America

Abstract

A comprehensive understanding of carbon cycling pathways in the soil-plant system is needed to develop models that accurately predict global carbon reservoir responses to anthropogenic perturbations. Honey is a carbon-rich natural food produced by wild and managed pollinating insects all over the world; the composition of a single sample is a function of millions of pollinator-plant interactions. We studied the 13C/12C and Δ14C of 121 honey samples sourced from the United States, and found a significant old carbon contribution. The effect is observed from 25 to 45° latitude, not correlated with 13C/12C, and consistent with a previously published study on European honeys. In specific cases, the measured values were up to 20 ‰ (Δ14C) higher than the expected atmospheric 14CO2 value for the given year, which shows a significant old carbon contribution. We hypothesize that the older carbon is from plant liquids derived in part from soil carbon or stored nonstructural carbohydrates from plants, which shifts the calibrated age of the sample by 5 years or more. Our work is the first to describe the widespread occurrence of old carbon in honey and shows that radiocarbon measurements can be a powerful tool to trace carbon allocations in terrestrial food webs and detect the atmosphere-soil-plant carbon cycle contributions.