Is there any difference between intermediate-acting and long-acting calcium antagonists in diurnal blood pressure and autonomic nervous activity in hypertensive coronary artery disease patients?

Abstract

Recently, there have been some reports indicating that calcium antagonists induce a reflex increase in sympathetic activity, triggering cardiac events, especially in coronary artery disease (CAD) patients. In this study, we assessed heart rate (HR) variability (HRV) using power spectral analysis of the 24-h RR interval in 25 hypertensive outpatients with CAD treated with nifedipine. We compared blood pressure (BP), HR, and HRV variation in the same patients substituting benidipine (long-acting) for nifedipine (intermediate-acting). There were no significant differences in 24-h, daytime, nighttime, and morning BP between the nifedipine phase and the benidipine phase. HRV parameters (LF: low frequency power, HF: high frequency power, LF/HF ratio) also showed no significant differences in 24-h, daytime, nighttime, and morning LF, HF, and LF/HF ratio between the nifedipine phase and the benidipine phase. Blood pressure, HR, and HRV parameters, except the LF component from 2 to 4 h after nifedipine administration (the most effective duration), showed no differences compared to before administration. The LF component after the nifedipine administration was lower than before administration. In conclusion, in hypertensive patients with CAD, whose BP levels were well-controlled by twice-daily use of intermediate-acting nifedipine, switching from nifedipine to a long-acting calcium antagonist, benidipine, maintained well-controlled BP levels to a similar degree, but it may not have additional benefit in sympatho-vagal balance.