Is the Small Ossicle of Type 1 Accessory Navicular a Cause of Foot Pain?-A Case Report.

Abstract

Background and objectives: An accessory navicular (AN) bone is often classified into types 1-3 according to the Veitch classification, and symptomatic type 1 patients usually receive non-surgical treatment. However, there are cases in which AN cannot be classified into one of these three types using this classification system, and the small ossicle of type 1 AN may not be the cause of foot pain. This report aimed to present a case of symptomatic type 1 AN that required surgical treatment without the excision of the small ossicle after long-term conservative treatment had failed. Case presentation: A 15-year-old girl who was diagnosed with symptomatic type 1 AN was referred to our department. Medial-side foot pain had prevented her from playing soccer well. She had been treated conservatively for type 1 AN for more than 12 months at several orthopedic clinics. Tenderness of the prominent navicular tubercle was identified, and computed tomography and magnetic resonance imaging findings suggested that the cause of her foot pain was derived from the prominent navicular tubercle not the small ossicle itself. Osteotomy of the prominent navicular tubercle with the advancement of the tibialis posterior tendon, without excision of the ossicle, was performed. At the 12-month follow-up examination, she was completely free from foot pain, and the patient-reported outcome measures were excellent. She now plays soccer at the pre-injury level. Conclusions: We report the case of a patient with symptomatic type 1 AN who underwent osteotomy of the prominent navicular tubercle with advancement of the tibialis posterior tendon, without excision of the ossicle, and who showed favorable short-term clinical outcomes. The evaluation of symptomatic patients with AN based on the Veitch classification alone may lead to inappropriate management. The small ossicle of type 1 AN was not the cause of foot pain in the present case.