Is the popliteal tendon sufficient for all-inside suture in lateral meniscus repair? A 22-case cadaver study

Abstract

IntroductionArthroscopic lateral meniscus repair is performed in the “figure-of-4 position” (supine, with the affected knee flexed and the lower leg crossed over the extended contralateral leg), and anchorage is often on the popliteal tendon. Extending the limb at the end of the procedure alters the relations between the popliteal tendon and the repaired meniscus. The present study aimed to assess lateral meniscal suture fixation on the popliteal tendon after a cycle of flexion-extension. HypothesisExtending the knee can induce suture release. Type of studyCadaver study. Materials and methodsTwenty-two fresh adult human cadaver knee specimens were used. Under arthroscopy with all-inside implants, a vertical suture onto the popliteal tendon was performed through the lateral meniscus. Suture status was assessed under arthroscopy after a cycle of flexion-extension, and deemed defective if the suture was sufficiently loose for the arthroscope to be able to be passed through the popliteal hiatus, if the stitch had passed through the meniscus, or if the suture was broken. ResultsThirteen sutures (59.1%) remained well fixed, and 9 (40.1%) were defective: 4 (18.2%) were loose, in 4 (18.2%) the stitch had passed through the meniscus, and in 1 (4.5%) the suture had broken. ConclusionIn a population of elderly cadaver knee specimens, arthroscopic suture of the lateral meniscus to the popliteal tendon was defective after flexion-extension in 40% of cases. Stress seems to be exerted on the suture when extension is resumed. Thus, a single stitch seems insufficient for stable lateral meniscus repair. Clinical implicationsSuture of the lateral meniscus to the popliteal tendon undergoes stress when extension is resumed, potentially causing failure of lateral meniscus repair. Level of evidenceIV.