Is Technical Analysis Profitable on Renewable Energy Stocks? Evidence from Trend-Reinforcing, Mean-Reverting and Hybrid Fractal Trading Systems

Abstract

Demand for power sources is gradually shifting from ozone-depleting-substances towards renewable and sustainable energy resources. The growth prospects of the renewable energy industry coupled with improved cost efficiency means that renewable energy companies offer potential returns for traders in stock markets. Nonetheless, there have been no studies investigating technical trading rules in renewable energy stocks by amalgamating fractal geometry with technical indicators that focus on different market phases. In this paper, we explore the profitability of technical analysis using a portfolio of 20 component stocks from the NASDAQ OMX Renewable Energy Generation Index using fractal dimension together with trend-reinforcing and mean-reverting (contrarian) indicators. Using daily prices for the period 1 July 2012 to 30 June 2022, we apply several tests to measure trading performance and risk-return dynamics of each form of technical trading system—both in isolation and simultaneously. Overall, trend (contrarian) trading system outperforms (underperforms) the naïve buy-and-hold policy on a risk-adjusted basis, while the outcome is further enhanced (reduced) by the fractal-reinforced strategy. Simultaneous use of both trend-reinforcing and mean-reverting indicators strengthened by fractal geometry generates the best risk-return trade-off, significantly outperforming the benchmark. Our findings suggest that renewable energy stock prices do not fully capture historical price patterns, allowing traders to earn significant profits from the weak form market inefficiency.