Is proximal femoral nailing a good procedure for teaching in orthogeriatrics?

Abstract

Proximal femoral nailing is a common operation in orthogeriatrics and a highly standardized procedure. For teaching purposes, this operation is often performed by residents and supervised by attending physicians. The objective of this study is to investigate if teaching this operation influences the surgical in-house complication rate. All patients who received a proximal femoral Targon PF nail (Aesculap AG, Tuttlingen, Germany) for trochanteric fractures were included in a cohort at our urban academic teaching hospital between 1998 and 2010. To evaluate potential effects of patient age, we separately analyzed several age groups. Complications including wound infection, hematoma, intraoperative malreduction or implant malpositioning causing revision, pain, cut-out and readmission due to nonunion were recorded. Our collective consists of 1,516 patients (m/f: 410/1,106). The mean age was 78.7years (range: 19-103years). The overall complication rate was 7.9%. In 857 cases operated by attending physicians, the complication rate was 6.9%. However in the 659 operations performed by residents, we found a higher complication rate of 9.3%. Further investigating this difference by χ(2) test, we found no significance (p=0.09). Whilst analyzing the complication rates for the different age groups, we did not find a statistically significant difference except in the age group between 71 and 80years, for which the odds ratio indicated a 2.6-fold increased complication risk for operations performed by residents (p=0.01). Further analysis revealed that this increased complication rate was mainly due to increased numbers of cut-out. We conclude that proximal femoral nailing is an operation suitable for teaching purposes. However, patients between 71 and 80years of age seem to be at an increased risk for cut-out if operated by a resident.